Creamy Seafood Salad with Imitation Crab

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

Three summers ago, I was at this beach rental with my family and we ran out of meal ideas by day four. Found some imitation crab in the fridge that nobody claimed, had mayo and celery, and just started throwing stuff together. Ended up with this salad that we ate for lunch two days straight.

Now I make it at home all the time, nowhere near a beach.

The Beauty of Fake Crab

Look, I’m not pretending this is lobster salad or something fancy. It’s imitation crab and there’s zero shame in that game. Real crab costs more than my electric bill. This stuff? Cheap and cheerful.

And here’s the thing – once you mix it with all the creamy dressing and crunchy bits, it tastes great anyway. Nobody’s ever taken a bite at a cookout and been like “excuse me, is this REAL crab?” They’re too busy eating it.

Why This Recipe Hits

It’s basically impossible to screw up. If you can open packages and stir things in a bowl, you’re qualified to make this.

Takes maybe ten minutes of actual work. Then it sits in the fridge doing its thing while you do yours.

Feeds a bunch of people without breaking the bank. Last time I made it for a neighborhood thing, total cost was like twelve bucks and fed eight people.

Everyone eats it. Kids, grandparents, that one friend who’s weirdly picky about everything. Universal appeal right here.

Ingredients You Need

Imitation crab meat – One pound. That’s two of those plastic packages they sell at the grocery store. Usually near the real seafood.

Mayo – One cup. Before you freak out, remember you’re splitting this between four people. If you want to cut it with plain Greek yogurt, go for it.

Fresh lemon juice – About a tablespoon. Squeeze a real lemon if you’ve got one. The bottled stuff is fine if you don’t.

Dijon mustard – Just a teaspoon but it matters. Regular yellow mustard works in a pinch.

Celery stalks – Chop up enough to make half a cup. Cut it small or people will complain.

Red onion – Quarter cup, minced. White or yellow onion works too but red looks prettier.

Corn kernels – Half a cup. Drain a can or thaw some frozen. Your call.

Fresh dill – If you’ve got it, great. If not, don’t stress. Maybe a tablespoon chopped up.

Lettuce – Whatever kind you like for serving.

Salt and pepper – The basics.

Throwing It Together

Grab your biggest mixing bowl. Dump in the mayo, squeeze in the lemon juice, add the mustard. Stir that around until it looks like one thing instead of three separate things.

Open up your imitation crab packages. Break the crab apart into chunks – not tiny shreds, but not huge logs either. Somewhere in between. Toss it in the bowl and fold it into that dressing you made.

Chop up your celery small. Like, really small. Same with the onion – mince it good. Nobody wants a mouthful of raw onion surprise. Add both to the bowl along with the corn.

Mix everything together but be gentle about it. You’re combining ingredients, not beating them into submission.

Sprinkle in some salt and pepper. Taste it. Add more if needed. If you’re using dill, toss that in and give it one more stir.

Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or a lid and stick it in the fridge. Leave it there for at least thirty minutes. An hour is better. Make it in the morning if you’re eating it for lunch.

When it’s time to eat, wash some lettuce leaves and put them on plates. Scoop the salad on top. Done.

What I’ve Figured Out

Cold is crucial. Room temp seafood salad is nasty. Let it chill proper before serving.

Tiny vegetables matter. Big chunks of celery or onion ruin the vibe. Take the extra minute to chop things small.

Adjust the mayo. My recipe says one cup but you might like less. Start with three-quarters and see how it feels.

The corn isn’t traditional but it’s the best part. Don’t leave it out just because it seems random.

Make it ahead. Gets better after sitting overnight. All the flavors get cozy together.

Ways to Change It Up

This base recipe is solid but you can mess with it.

Toss in some halved grapes. Sounds bonkers but sweet fruit with the savory crab is actually really good. My dentist does this version and swears by it.

Need protein? Chop up a couple hard-boiled eggs and mix them in. Makes it more substantial.

Want crunch? Dice up a green apple. Keeps it texture interesting.

Like spice? Dash in some hot sauce or sprinkle cayenne in the dressing.

Got leftover cooked shrimp? Chop those up and add them. Fancy it up a bit.

How to Serve This

I keep it simple – just pile it on some lettuce and call it lunch.

But you can also:

• Make sandwiches with it on whatever bread you like
• Spread it on crackers for an appetizer situation
• Stuff it in a tortilla wrap with extra lettuce
• Scoop it into hollowed-out tomatoes if you’re being fancy

Good for:

• Quick weekday lunches when you’re tired of sandwiches
• Backyard barbecues as a side dish
• Taking to someone’s house when they say “bring something”
• Hot summer days when you don’t want to cook

My dad likes to eat it with potato chips on the side and use the chips to scoop it up. Not how I do it but he’s happy.

Getting Ahead of Things

This is perfect for meal prep. Make it Sunday, eat it through Wednesday. After that it starts getting watery.

Bringing it somewhere? Make it the night before so you’re not rushing around day-of. Just keep it cold in a cooler with ice packs.

Whatever you do, don’t let it sit out in the heat. Mayo-based food and sunshine don’t mix well. Learned that at an outdoor wedding once. Not pretty.

Bottom Line

This isn’t trying to be gourmet. It’s just a solid, tasty salad that comes together fast and tastes good. Sometimes that’s exactly what you need.

Works for feeding yourself lunch all week or bringing to share with a crowd. Either way, you’ll probably end up making it again.